All Fresh Seafood Reviews
All Fresh Seafood has an overall rating of 3.9 based on 84 reviews. Customer feedback on All Fresh Seafood is mixed: All Fresh Seafood reviewers highlight positive aspects like fresh seafood quality, prompt delivery, excellent customer service, wide variety of products, which strongly appeal to seafood enthusiasts, health-conscious consumers, home cooks, gourmet food lovers. However, All Fresh Seafood is often criticized for its higher price point, occasional shipping issues, limited local availability, website navigation challenges.
84 reviews
5 Stars
2
4 Stars
3
3 Stars
1
2 Stars
1
1 Star
0
How would you rate All Fresh Seafood?
All All Fresh Seafood Reviews (84)
Sherry.pitts
May 18, 2026
"Fish was alright, but the warm delivery left me annoyed"
I ordered from All Fresh Seafood, and when the box showed up, it already looked rough. One corner was wet, the gel packs were mostly melted, and it made me feel like I had to beg for the basic thing I paid for: seafood that actually arrives properly chilled.
The fish itself didn’t smell bad, so I cooked it that same day just to be safe, but I couldn’t really enjoy it without feeling a little resentful about the whole situation. It was okay in the end, but for fresh seafood, the packaging and temperature really should’ve been better.
The fish itself didn’t smell bad, so I cooked it that same day just to be safe, but I couldn’t really enjoy it without feeling a little resentful about the whole situation. It was okay in the end, but for fresh seafood, the packaging and temperature really should’ve been better.
0
Reply
stephanie_Colon93
May 09, 2026
"Fresh fish, good overall"
Nice. The fish was good quality and tasted mostly fresh. Happy with it overall.
0
Reply
james-Clark
April 30, 2026
"I found the site really easy to use..."
I found the site really easy to use and was able to find what I wanted fast. Checkout was quick too, and you don’t have to guess what to do next because everything is clear. It was my first time ordering from All Fresh Seafood, it went smoothly with no hassle. I’d definitely use them again.
0
Reply
rose.Evans
April 15, 2026
"Used to feel like a better deal"
The seafood was still decent, but I remember it being better for the price. This time it felt a little pricey for what I got. Not bad by any means, just not the great value it used to be...
0
Reply
David.lucas
February 05, 2026
"Showed up fast, solid overall"
I ordered from All Fresh Seafood and it got here faster than I thought it would, which was a nice surprise. The box was still cold, everything looked packed properly, and nothing seemed off. Tracking was decent enough, not amazing, but I could tell where it was most of the time and it arrived on the day they said it would. So yeah, no real complaints there. I’m only leaving off a star because I kind of wanted more detailed updates, especially with seafood being shipped, but overall it was reliable and I’d probably order from them again
0
Reply
RandallBlack_23
January 01, 2026
"Support got back to me fast"
I reached out with an issue and they replied way quicker than I expected. They got it fixed without any hassle, which was great
0
Reply
stephanie_Mcdaniel98
December 05, 2025
"Everything I ordered was in the box and..."
Everything I ordered was in the box and it showed up right when they said it would. No mix-ups or hassle, so the whole order was easy. I’d definitely order from them again.
0
Reply
Have a question about All Fresh Seafood?
Log in to ask your All Fresh Seafood question!
Customer Reviews
Ask a Question
